ALAMEDA-CONTRA COSTA TRANSIT DISTRICT  
MINUTES  
AC Transit Parcel Tax Fiscal Oversight Committee  
VIRTUAL MEETING  
Phone (669) 900 6833  
Webinar ID 895 2964 0027  
Tuesday, November 9, 2021 at 8:30 AM  
https://bit.ly/3FaGokD  
MEMBERS OF THE OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE  
JANET ABELSON  
STEWART CHEN  
STEPHEN HICKS  
BEVERLY JOHNSON  
HENRY LEVY  
IGOR TREGUB  
MATT WILLIAMS  
DISTRICT OFFICERS  
MICHAEL A. HURSH, GENERAL MANAGER  
JILL A. SPRAGUE, GENERAL COUNSEL  
LINDA A. NEMEROFF, DISTRICT SECRETARY  
CHRIS ANDRICHAK, CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER  
1.  
CALL TO ORDER  
The Alameda-Contra Costa Parcel Tax Fiscal Oversight Committee held its annual meeting on  
Tuesday, November 9, 2021.  
Members of the Committee participated via video conference from off-site locations.  
The meeting was called to order at 8:38 a.m.  
2.  
3.  
ROLL CALL  
Member Williams joined the meeting at 9:05 AM.  
Present  
Chair Janet Abelson*, Committee Member Beverly Johnson, Committee  
Member Michael Gregory, Committee Member Matt Williams, Committee  
Member Henry Levy, Committee Member Stewart Chen, Committee  
Member Igor Tregub  
SELECTION OF CHAIR  
Member Gregory welcomed the new members and encouraged the Committee to participate  
in the chair selection process. Assistant District Secretary Jelena Harada called for nominations  
for Chair. Member Chen nominated Member Abelson which was seconded by Member Levy.  
No other nominations were offered.  
MOTION: CHEN/LEVY to appoint Janet Abelson as the Committee Chair. The motion carried by  
the following vote:  
Ayes:  
Chair Abelson*, Committee Member Johnson, Committee Member Gregory,  
Committee Member Levy, Committee Member Chen, Committee Member  
Tregub  
Absent:  
Committee Member Williams  
4.  
5.  
PUBLIC COMMENT  
There were no public comments offered.  
CONSENT CALENDAR  
5.A. Consider approving the minutes of the Parcel Tax Fiscal Oversight  
Committee meeting of November 12, 2020.  
MOTION: JOHNSON/TREGUB to approve the minutes of the Parcel Tax Fiscal Oversight  
Committee meeting of November 12, 2020. The motion carried by the following vote:  
Ayes:  
Chair Abelson*, Committee Member Johnson, Committee Member Gregory,  
Committee Member Levy, Committee Member Chen, Committee Member  
Tregub  
Absent:  
Committee Member Williams  
6.  
DISCUSSION ITEMS  
6.A. Review the Measure VV/C1 Financial Statement and consider the  
adoption of Resolution No. 21-001 determining that the Measure  
VV/C1 funds collected during the 2020-21 Fiscal Year have been  
appropriated and expended in Special Transit Service District No. 1 for  
operation and maintenance activities.  
-
-
History of the District 1 - District 2 Allocation Methodology;  
Measure VV/C1 Agreed Upon Procedure, including an Hours and  
Miles Comparison for District 1/District 2;  
AC Transit Audited Financial Statements (includes the D1/D2  
-
Report and Supplemental Schedule).  
Chief Financial Officer Chris Andrichak briefly presented the status of the District's  
finances and introduced the presenters. Ken Myers presented information on the  
allocation methodology and the allocation of revenue, subsidies, and expenses. Brad  
Schelle, an independent external auditor with Crow LLC, reviewed the Measure VV/C1  
agreed-upon procedures applicable to the audit. Mr. Schelle explained that Measure  
VV/C1 funds collected during the 2020-21 Fiscal Year had been appropriated and  
expended in Special Transit Service District No. 1 for operation and maintenance  
activities as prescribed by the agreed-upon procedures.  
Chair Abelson asked a about the allocation of funds between the two special districts.  
Staff explained the allocation methodology that applies to expenses, which are based  
on the service hours in each District and compared to the total number of hours, and  
also based on service miles in each District compared to total numbers of miles. Mr.  
Myers further referred to the established and agreed-upon formula and allocation  
methodology.  
Chair Abelson asked about the paratransit division of expenses and whether it was  
based on the fact that all customer requests were fulfilled without a denial of service.  
Mr. Myers confirmed that to be true and that division of expenses for paratransit  
services was split between the two special districts based on the services reported by  
the paratransit contractor.  
Member Chen asked a general question about the District's Budget that was addressed  
by staff. Chair Abelson commented that a portion of sales taxes collected from online  
commerce contributed positively to the District's revenues.  
Member Tregub commented that total service hours, service miles, and hours  
decreased in the past fiscal year and asked if staff plans to address the issue. Though  
beyond the Committee's scope, General Manager Hursh addressed the question,  
explaining that the unavailability of bus operators and change in transportation needs  
have contributed to the change in service. He further clarified that staff is aggressively  
recruiting bus operators and gauging the transit needs to redesign the service network.  
Mr. Hursh referred the Committee to recent Board discussions about the established  
methodology for prioritizing lines in service restoration. Mr. Hursh also addressed a  
question about the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds.  
Member Levy commented about the Committee's charge related to the expenditures in  
Special District 1 and asked whether it has any input on determining the methodology  
of how allocations are divided between the two Special Districts. Chief Financial Officer  
Andrichak explained that the Committee is charged with approving the expenditure  
statement of collected property taxes in Special District 1 based on the agreed-upon  
procedures and established methodology. He further clarified that the reasoning for  
methodology and service planning would be in the purview of the AC Transit Board of  
Directors.  
Director of Service Development and Planning Robert del Rosario briefly clarified how  
service hours and service miles are determined and allocated in each of the two special  
districts.  
Member Levy commented on a typographical error on page 36 of the meeting packet  
which should read "gain" instead of "loss".  
Member Chen commented on a taxpayers' parcel tax obligation to AC Transit. Staff  
clarified the definition of parcel tax as it related to AC Transit's revenues and agreed to  
add the clarification to the future meetings' materials.  
MOTION: JOHNSON/GREGORY to adopt Resolution No. 21-001 determining that the  
Measure VV/C1 funds collected during the 2020-21 Fiscal Year have been appropriated  
and expended in Special Transit Service District No. 1 for operation and maintenance  
activities. The motion carried by the following vote:  
Ayes:  
Chair Abelson*, Committee Member Johnson, Committee Member Gregory,  
Committee Member Williams, Committee Member Levy, Committee  
Member Chen, Committee Member Tregub  
6.B. SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION PACKET (for reference only)  
The Supplemental Information Packet was not under consideration by the Committee  
and is only intended to provide relevant background information.  
7.  
8.  
COMMITTEE/STAFF COMMENTS  
There were no comments offered.  
ADJOURNMENT  
There being no further business to come before the Committee the meeting adjourned at 9:24  
AM.  
Respectfully submitted,  
/s/  
Jelena Harada  
Assistant District Secretary